Galtland Index

Carl Menger

4 min read

Carl Menger

Carl Menger (1840–1921) is the founder of Austrian Economics. His 1871 Grundsätze der Volkswirtschaftslehre — his foundational Principles — launched the marginal-utility revolution on subjectivist, methodologically individualist lines; his 1892 essay On the Origins of Money then derived money itself as a spontaneous, unplanned institution — the outcome of self-interested exchange, not of legislation. That account is the headwater of the wiki’s monetary thread, from Mises’s regression theorem to the unforgeable costliness of digital money.

The Origin of Money

Menger’s question is how a single commonly accepted medium of exchange could ever arise. The puzzle is that money seems to presuppose itself: no one accepts a good in trade unless others already do. His answer dispenses with both the “invention” story and the “state decree” story. Goods differ in their saleableness (salability) — the ease with which a holder can sell them, at any time, in any quantity, near their economic price. Cattle, grain, and trinkets are far less saleable than, eventually, the precious metals.

A self-interested trader who cannot directly barter for what he wants will accept, in the meantime, a good he does not want to consume — provided it is more saleable than what he holds — because it brings him closer to his goal. Once a few traders do this, the most-saleable commodities become even more saleable (more people will take them), in a self-reinforcing process. No one intends to create money; each is simply pursuing his own advantage. The most-saleable commodities are thereby selected, by the market, as general media of exchange. Money is, in Menger’s framing, an unintended social institution — a spontaneous order — and the state’s later role (coinage, legal standards) only perfects a money the market has already produced, rather than creating it.

Why He Matters in This Wiki

Menger is the source node for the Austrian theory of money the wiki builds on repeatedly. Mises’s regression theorem in The Theory of Money and Credit extends Menger’s account backward in time: a money’s purchasing power traces to its value as an ordinary commodity before it became money. Szabo’s Shelling Out restates the saleableness story for prehistoric collectibles and carries it forward to digital scarcity; hard money and unforgeable costliness are the monetary virtues the same lineage prizes, and Bitcoin is read as a candidate Mengerian money that bootstraps saleableness from scratch. Menger also anchors the school itself: Böhm-Bawerk and Mises build the capital-and-money theory on the subjectivist, marginalist foundation he laid.

See Also

  • Austrian Economics - the school Menger founded
  • Ludwig von Mises - extended Menger’s money theory into the regression theorem
  • The Theory of Money and Credit - Mises’s development of Mengerian monetary origins
  • Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk - second-generation Austrian who built on Menger’s subjectivism
  • Shelling Out - Szabo’s Mengerian account of collectibles as proto-money
  • Hard Money - the monetary hardness the saleableness lineage prizes
  • Unforgeable Costliness - the digital-money primitive descending from this account
  • Bitcoin - read as a candidate Mengerian money
  • Nick Szabo - cypherpunk who carried the Mengerian account into digital money
  • The Subjective Theory of Value vs. the Labor Theory of Value - The clash between value as objective embodied labor (Marx) and value as the subjective, marginal importance imputed by acting individuals (Menger, Böhm-Bawerk, Mises).
  • Karl Marx - Author of Capital (1867) and the labor theory of value — value as socially necessary labour-time embodied in goods; the principal foil to the Austrian subjective theory of value.
  • Principles of Economics (Menger) - Menger’s 1871 founding text of the Austrian School: value is a subjective judgment of a good’s importance for satisfying needs, never a property inherent in the good
  • The Regression Theorem - Mises’s proof that money’s value today traces back to a good’s original non-monetary worth, dissolving the circularity of valuing money and forbidding a money with no prior value.

Sources

Graph View

Backlinks